The Salary Number You Should NEVER Say First

Picture this: You're sitting in a job interview, your heart pounding as the conversation turns to salary expectations. The interviewer asks, "What salary range are you looking for?" Suddenly, you're caught between undervaluing yourself with a low number or pricing yourself out of the job. You're not alone—65% of job seekers feel pressured to give a salary figure first during interviews (JobSeeker Insights 2024). But what if I told you that giving a number first might be a mistake you don't want to make?

The Problem Everyone Ignores

It's a silent struggle many face, yet few address head-on: the anxiety of saying the wrong number. You’re not just negotiating money; you're negotiating your worth. I’ve heard countless stories like yours. One job seeker told me, "I once gave a salary expectation that was way lower than I should have, and I regretted it the entire time I worked there." The fear of undervaluing yourself is not just mental—it's financial and emotional. According to the HR Trends Report 2025, companies that disclose their salary range upfront see a 20% increase in candidate applications. Isn’t it time more companies took this approach? Until then, let's explore why giving a salary number first can backfire and how you can avoid this common pitfall.

Why The typical approach Doesn't Work

Conventional wisdom might tell you to be upfront and straightforward, but in salary negotiations, this approach is often a one-way ticket to self-doubt. When you throw out a number first, you risk either undervaluing yourself or scaring off the potential employer. One job seeker shared, "I always feel like I’m just shooting myself in the foot when I give a number first. Why can’t they just tell me their range?" Valid question, right? The truth is, employers often have a budget in mind, and by speaking first, you might place yourself outside of it.

The system is skewed—we're in a culture where discussing money is taboo, and the power dynamics of a job interview amplify this discomfort. But awareness is power. Let's shift gears and look at what does work.

The 3 Things That Actually Work

So, how can you navigate these salary conversations with confidence? Here are three practical steps you can follow:

Step 1: Deflect and Redirect

When the salary question arises, try deflecting it back to the employer. A simple script you can use is: "I’m really excited about the opportunity to work with your team and I’d love to learn more about the role and responsibilities. Could you share more about the salary range for this position?" This not only shows your interest but also puts the ball back in their court.

Step 2: Do Your Research

Understanding industry standards is key. Use resources like salary comparison websites and talk to peers in your industry to get a sense of what's typical. One common approach is to say something like, "From my research and industry standards, I understand similar roles are in the range of $X to $Y. Does this align with your budget for the position?" This not only shows that you're informed but also places your expectation within a realistic context.

Step 3: Know Your Worth

This is about more than just a number—it's about knowing your value and what you bring to the table. Reflect on your skills, experience, and the unique contributions you can make. When you have a clear sense of your worth, you’re better equipped to stand firm and negotiate effectively. Try this: "Based on my skills and experience, I believe a salary range of $X to $Y reflects my qualifications. However, I'm open to discussing this further to ensure we find a mutually beneficial agreement."

Common Mistakes to Avoid

Even the best strategies can fumble if common mistakes aren’t avoided:

• Speaking too soon: Jumping in with a number at the first chance can undermine your position.
• Lack of research: Not knowing industry standards can leave you either underselling or overselling yourself.
• Undervaluing confidence: Remember, confidence is key. Employers can sense uncertainty, which can lead to lower offers.

Your Next Step

Feeling more confident about the next interview? The key takeaway here is to keep the conversation open and informed, ensuring both parties can come to a fair agreement. Ready to negotiate with confidence? Our salary research tools can help you find the right range quickly and easily, giving you the upper hand in any salary discussion.

---

Part of our salary series for job seekers.